In one of the most famously tragic love triangles of our time, Amy Fisher shot the wife of Joey Buttafuoco, the man she was a mistress to while in high school, TIME reported. At the time, Amy was 17 years old, while Buttafuoco and his wife, Mary Jo Buttafuoco, were in their late 30s.
Amy carried out the shooting on May 19, 1992, when she showed up at her lover’s home in Massapequa, N.Y. Miraculously, Mary Jo survived after being shot in the head with a .25-caliber handgun.
In a new Lifetime film titled “I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco,” executive produced by Mary Jo, she tells the story of her shocking experience through her own words. “Everyone’s fighting about the truth. I was fighting for my life!” Mary Jo stated in the film’s trailer.
While Mary Jo has found a different sense of closure through her Lifetime film, which premiered on Jan. 17, many are left wondering where her ex-husband, Joey, and his former lover are today. Here’s everything to know:
Where Is Joey Buttafuoco Today?
Joey served four months in jail in 1993 after being found guilty of his relationship with the minor. Mary Jo stayed with Joey after she was shot by his mistress, divorcing in 2003.
Before Joey was convicted, he worked in the automobile industry, owning his own repair shop. According to his IMDb, Joey has made his way into Hollywood fame. He appeared in several films, including “Pervasions of Science” in 1997, “The Underground Comedy Movie” in 1999 and “Finding Forrester” in 2000.
He was remarried to Evanka Franjko in 2005 and is still married to her today.
Where Is Amy Fisher the ‘Long Island Lolita’ Today?
Amy served seven years in prison after she was found guilty of first-degree assault in the 1992 shooting of Mary Jo. She then relocated to Florida before traveling back to Long Island, telling the New York Post in 2017 that her kids were “ostracized” due to families thinking she would break their marriages up as well.
According to the outlet, Amy got married in 2003 to ex-cop Lou Bellera, who is 24 years her senior. They later divorced in 2015 after welcoming three children together. The tumultuous aftermath of her divorce led her to appear on “Celebrity Rehab with Dr. Drew” in 2011.
Amy turned her story into a New York Times bestseller after her biography, “If I Knew Then…,” was published in 2004. She was also a columnist for the Long Island Press, A&E reported.
Shame on Amy… She didn’t get very far in life staring in xxxxx rated movies. Onec a whore always a whore. She should have been locked up for life along with Joey. What they did to his wife was sooo bad. Both got off easy. But even today his x wife still suffers. She is in pain every day of her life. The two dirt bags got off easy. But they both will be judge from a much higher power someday soon…PERIOD
So correct. What court sentenced them? They should have been put away for a very long time.