Andrew Spencer didn’t find love when he was a contestant on Katie Thurston’s season 17 of “The Bachelorette” or season 8 of “Bachelor in Paradise.” However, he was given another shot at the beach for BiP season 10, where he met Alexe Godin, with the couple going to the finale, winning a $125,000 prize, and still going strong today.
Both Spencer and Godin have shared relationship updates with fans on Instagram, and most recently, attended Coachella together. Spencer shared a video of watching Justin Bieber’s Coachella set with Godin, but in a second photo, shared a surprising DM he received from the singer back in 2021, calling it “a full circle moment.”
Andrew Spencer Shares the Sweet DM He Received From Justin Bieber During His Time on ‘The Bachelorette’
“Bachelor in Paradise” star Andrew Spencer recently took to Instagram to share how seeing Justin Bieber’s 2026 Coachella performance was “a full circle moment” for him.
Spencer shared a clip of Bieber recreating his cover of Chris Brown’s “With You” song and then panned the camera to his girlfriend, Alexe Godin, who teared up as she sang along. In a second photo, Spencer shared a direct message he received from Bieber himself, who declared he and his wife, Hailey Bieber, were rooting for him when he appeared on season 21 of “The Bachelorette.”
The DM, sent from Bieber on August 2, 2021, to Spencer read, “My boy, my wife and I just watched you on ‘The Bachelorette’ and just wanted to say that you were our fav. Wishing you the best of luck on your journey and we know that you will find someone perfect for you.”
Spencer replied to the “Peaches” singer, sharing, “Appreciate it man, means a lot coming from you two. No doubt that my person’s out there. If you know anyone that’s a match, let your boy know.” Bieber later “loved” the comment.
Bachelor Nation Reacts to Bieber’s DM to Spencer
Bachelor Nation quickly flooded the comment section of Spencer’s post, including Katie Thurston, who eliminated Spencer when he appeared on her season.
“I had to check the date. 😂 for some reason I’m feeing embarrassed. Knowing those two were pissed I sent you home. Im sorry Bieber fam!” She joked.
“The Bachelor” season 28 lead Joey Graziadei called the DM a “heavy flex,” while “The Bachelor” season 26 contestant Serene Russell wrote, “excuse me everyone would have to know this lil fun fact about me if this had happened to me 😅 how’d you hold this in for so long hahah.”
According to “The Bachelorette” season 11 lead Kaitlyn Bristowe, she and Spencer have a small history with the Biebs. “Remember when we sent him a video and he called us funny? I still think about that probably way too often. I love this. And yall are so cutie,” she wrote.
