When Hallmark Channel airs a “Finding Mr. Christmas” cast reunion special on December 20, 2025, fans may not recognize some of their favorite contestants!
All 10 guys who were vying for a shot at a major role in a Hallmark Christmas movie reconvened for the special looking awfully spiffy. Photos released in advance by Hallmark reveals some even sported new looks to chat with host (and series co-creator) Jonathan Bennett and lead judge Melissa Peterman. Check out the most dramatic makeovers…
‘Finding Mr. Christmas’ Finalist Rustin Sailors, Is That You??
HallmarkTop 3 finalist Rustin Cole Sailors, 37, showed up to the “Finding Mr. Christmas” reunion looking like a totally different person! Clean-shaven and no longer sporting his long, curly locks, the San Diego musician and actor debuted his new look on Instagram in late September, as he took the stage at the Tony Award-winning South Coast Repertory, portraying Elvis Presley in “Million Dollar Quartet.”
Angel Garet Goes Sleek & Chic After ‘Finding Mr. Christmas’
HallmarkAngel Garet, who was also a Top 3 contender, was sporting a shorter haircut in the finale episode of “Finding Mr. Christmas,” but his look for the reunion special was a shift from cute & cozy to muy caliente! Garet, 39, grew his hair and — gasp — is that chest hair we see?! We just hope he’s still a total softy behind the glow-up.
How Did Logan Shephard Fly Under Our Radar?
HallmarkExcuse us, but where was this Logan Shephard during “Finding Mr. Christmas!?” Maybe it was the Christmas sweaters or the curtain bangs, but we did not detect the hotness that Shephard, 31, brought to the reunion! The new hair, the fuller beard, the open collar, the confident gaze? Bring him back for season 3!
Winner Craig Geoghan Shows Off Subtle But Sizzling Changes
HallmarkWe couldn’t skip a then-and-now with “Finding Mr. Christmas” winner Craig Geoghan, even though the changes to his look are far more subtle. From less stubble to a highlight-free hairdo with shorter layers, Geoghan, 33, looks more movie star than north woods cutie. But we hope the sweet and funny guy inside is still showing up, too!
All About the ‘Finding Mr. Christmas’ Reunion
In the “Finding Mr. Christmas” reunion, Bennett will give viewers an “inside look” at season two, according to Hallmark. Viewers will find out what the guys have been up to since filming the unscripted competition in the spring of 2025.
Winner Craig Geoghan will also share what it was like to film his role as Hunter King’s brother in “A Make or Break Holiday,” which premieres right before the reunion. Hallmark promised “a few surprises along the way,” too. Among those surprises might be some of the guys’ makeovers since appearing on the show.
“A Make or Break Holiday” with Geoghan’s first major Hallmark role premieres on December 20 at 8 p.m. Eastern time and the “Finding Mr. Christmas” reunion airs right after, at 10 p.m. Eastern time.
