Tyler Hynes will find any “excuse” to bring the beloved Brenner brothers back for a “Three Wise Men” reunion. The Hallmark favorite recently weighed in on reuniting with his co-stars, Paul Campbell and Andrew Walker, and while nothing is officially in the works, Hynes made it clear he’s more than open to the possibility.
The “Three Wise Men” trilogy begins with the 2022 film “Three Wise Men and a Baby,” which is centered around three brothers, Luke (Walker), Taylor (Hynes), and Stephan (Campbell), who “get the surprise of their lives when they are forced to work together and care for a baby over the holidays,” according to the official synopsis on Hallmark Channel.
In 2024, the second film, “Three Wiser Men and a Boy,” is released, picking up the story of the Brenner brothers five years later when Luke enlists the help of Taylor and Stephan to help make his son’s dreams come true. “Three Wisest Men,” which was released in 2025, marks the final film in the trilogy, where the Brenner brothers have to conquer even greater challenges as their families grow and new opportunities arise.
Hynes Discusses a the Possibility of a Brenner Family Reunion
“I mean, those guys, I obviously love them to death,” Hynes said of his co-stars Campbell and Walker in an April 23 interview with Us Weekly while promoting his upcoming Hallmark film, “I’ll Be Seeing You,” which he produced and starred in.
The “It Was Always You” star continued, “I just saw Paul and Kim [Sustad] when I was in Vancouver, and we’re going to find ways to play around in the sand.”
“Honestly, we listen a lot to what our audience says and whether it’s the brothers or it’s some new adventure, we’ll find an excuse to disappoint everybody on screen,” Hynes joked.
Campbell Reveals ‘The Most Surprising Thing’ He Learned About Hynes
HallmarkBack in 2022, Campbell revealed the one thing he was surprised to learn about his co-star Hynes while they were filming “Three Wise Men and a Baby.”
“I think the most surprising thing is how good Tyler was with the babies. He was just like a natural-born baby whisperer,” Campbell said in an interview with PEOPLE while walking the red carpet at Hallmark’s “Countdown to Christmas” event that year. “He would take the crying baby, and he would just walk around whispering things to it.”
Campbell continued to share how Walker was equally as surprised by Hynes’ talent. He said, “Andrew and I would just go, ‘Oh, Tyler’s got this figured out.’ That goes on top of the résumé!”
“Working with a baby is so grounding,” Walker admitted while also speaking with the outlet on the red carpet. “You’re really at the mercy of the baby.”
Though Hynes doesn’t have any children in real life as of now, he remains a devoted dog dad to his adorable 6-year-old Pomeranian named Rusty James, who he frequently shares on social media and has become well-known among his fans.
