A third leaked audio clip from the “Summer House” reunion is now circulating online, offering the clearest look yet at the emotional fallout between Amanda Batula and Ciara Miller — and how the situation involving West Wilson ultimately unraveled.
The newly surfaced clip captures a tense exchange moderated by Andy Cohen, with Amanda directly addressing her actions and Ciara openly challenging her throughout the conversation.
The first audio leak came out on April 24th and the second on the 28th.
Amanda Admits Fear and Anticipates Fallout
In the clip, Andy asks Amanda about Ciara and her past with West. Amanda does not deflect.
“I was terrified,” she says. “I knew the truth would have to come out, no matter what. I knew I was going to have to tell her whether this was a short-term thing or something more.”
Kyle Cooke can be heard interjecting in the background, saying, “[West] was my friend,” before Amanda redirects the focus.
“This question was about Ciara right now,” she says.
Ciara Responds — and the Tone Shifts Immediately
The conversation escalates quickly when Ciara weighs in, making her stance unmistakably clear.
“They’re both snakes in the grass,” Ciara says to Kyle, referring to Amanda and West. “West is [expletive] up for doing that to you too. Like they’re both [expletive] weird.”
When Amanda begins to respond under her breath, Ciara immediately pushes her to speak up.
“Say it louder. What?” she says.
Amanda then expresses frustration with how the conversation is unfolding.
“I just won’t answer questions anymore because you keep talking,” she says.
Ciara fires back: “Why, because you’re being held accountable?”
Amanda responds: “No, because I’m not having an opportunity to speak.”
Accountability Becomes the Focus
Andy attempts to bring the conversation back under control, asking Amanda directly:
“Did you feel bad?”
“Yes,” Amanda says.
Ciara immediately challenges that answer.
“Clearly, no.”
As Amanda’s tone rises, she asks to be heard.
“If you could listen to what I’m saying instead of telling me that everything I’m saying is wrong, I would greatly appreciate that,” she says.
Ciara then delivers one of the most direct lines of the exchange.
“You’re a liar now. You have no credibility.”
Amanda responds: “OK, then why am I here?”
“I don’t know,” Ciara says.
Amanda Describes ‘Immense Guilt’ Over the Situation
Later in the clip, Andy presses further — this time about the message Amanda sent to Ciara to let her know about her new relationship with West.
“You felt how sending the text?” he asks.
Amanda offers one of her most detailed explanations yet.
“An immense amount of guilt. I was freaking out. Things were so fresh and new and I was confused and didn’t understand what was going on,” she says.
She continues: “The last thing I wanted to do was sit down with Ciara in that moment and be like, I don’t know what the [expletive] is happening.”
Amanda acknowledges, in hindsight, that she would have handled things differently.
“Should I have done that? A hundred thousand percent,” she says.
But she adds that fear ultimately drove her decisions.
“I was terrified because I knew no matter what, this was going to be a friendship dealbreaker for us — and that scared the [expletive] because I had already crossed the line.”
The Exchange Ends With More Questions Than Answers
Ciara continues to challenge Amanda’s version of events, at one point saying:
“You literally gallivanted around town.”
“I wasn’t gallivanting,” Amanda responds.
Kyle adds his own perspective near the end of the clip.
“I literally thought it could not be true… right up until the [expletive] end,” he says.
A Third Leak Deepens the Reunion Fallout
This latest audio clip follows two previously leaked segments, each adding new context to the timeline and relationships at the center of the season.
Bravo has already confirmed the recordings were unauthorized and launched an investigation into how the audio was distributed.
With three separate clips now circulating, the full reunion episode is shaping up to answer — and potentially amplify — the tensions that have defined the season.
Yes Amanda crossed the girl code line. But let’s be adults about this. Ciara you’ve been broken up with weather for at least 2 years and if West wanted to be with you he would have never broken up with you. He very Cleary told you when the two of you talked that your friendship was all he wanted from you. He never said anything else. You could have moved on by now. You cared way more for him. And for that he said he was sorry. I feel bad that your best friend fell for him. Personally you Ciara and Amanda are way to beautiful for him. What you girls see in him is way beyound us viewers. He’s not good looking by a long shot. He’s a sloppy dresser and is out of shape for a young guy. In the viewers opinion both you Ciara and Amanda are way to good looking for him. What the hell do either of you girls see in him. He must have a really good line of bullshit. To have two beautiful women fall for a sloppy looking guy like him. Yes Amanda is in a world win of bullshit with West. He’s the first guy who is giving her attention and helping her get over her breakup with Kyle. I know that’s no excuse to break girl code. But he knew excatly what to say and when to say it to her. We the fans said over and over again. Rebound romances rarely work out. West isn’t really ready for a long lasting relationship. So don’t be hurt now you finally see what kind of a guy he really is. Move on find your true love and then someday when the heat dies down than maybe you can have that girl talk with only you and Amanda. By that time you can say I could have told you so. West is not ready to settle down for a long time. Ciara you don’t need to be mean spirited with Amanda. Cause karma always has a way of coming back and bitting the people who hurted you in the ass. Just sit back and wait. Your time is coming. I only have pity for Amanda cause she was treated like crap for years from Kyle. So West knew excatly how to schmooze Amanda into getting her in bed and having a fling with her. Everybody should just let this romance play out. I give it a year……PERIOD