A second audio clip from the “Summer House” Season 10 reunion has surfaced online, offering new insight into the timeline — and shifting dynamics — between Amanda Batula, Kyle Cooke, Ciara Miller, and West Wilson. This news comes just days after the first leak from the reunion set.
The clip, which began circulating on Reddit, appears to capture a separate portion of the reunion conversation from the initial leak, with a clearer focus on what actually happened the night Amanda and West were first seen together by some of their castmates.
Amanda Pushes Back on How the Situation Is Being Framed
Early in the clip, Amanda addresses the ongoing scrutiny around her actions, suggesting there was no clear “right” way to handle the situation.
“I feel like it’s damned if you do, damned if you don’t. I handled it the way I thought was the right thing to do,” she says.
Kyle immediately challenges that explanation.
“Amanda, you’re well spoken. That was a word salad. One hundred percent it was a word salad,” he responds, referencing the statement her and West put out confirming their relationship.
The Night in Question — and Where West Fits In
The clip also helps clarify when the night in question took place — the night when Amanda and West were spotted by Kyle and Jesse Solomon, their other “Summer House” co-star.
Kyle explains that the group had been out earlier in the evening before arriving at the same location.
“We were coming from another bar… it was me and Jesse and a bunch of our friends. And West and Amanda were sitting next to each other,” he says.
When Andy Cohen asks for timing, Jesse answers:
“February 28.”
Amanda again downplays the situation.
“We were being silly. Yeah.”
Jesse later reveals he asked Amanda directly about West at the time.
“That was the first time I asked Amanda, like, are you hooking up with West? And she’s like, no. He’s just my boy.”
The Statement — and When Ciara Found Out
Another key part of the clip centers on the now widely discussed statement involving Amanda and West — and how it was communicated to the group.
When asked when she learned about it, Ciara says:
“Less than 24 hours before it came out. Amanda texted me basically admitting that her and West are whatever.”
When Andy asks if she responded, Ciara says simply: “No.”
West is also pulled into the conversation when Andy asks whether a PR person helped shape the statement.
“Clearly not,” West says.
Amanda briefly jokes about the situation, adding: “ChatGPT. I’m kidding. That was a joke.”
Lindsay Hubbard Raises Timeline Questions
Later in the clip, Lindsay Hubbard brings the focus back to the couple’s earlier separation announcement — and how the timeline may overlap.
“I just want to slow down for one second,” Lindsay says. “What I can’t stop thinking about is the first statement.”
She references speculation about Amanda spending time at West’s apartment earlier in the year.
Amanda firmly denies that version of events.
“I didn’t spend the night at West’s. I was not at West’s apartment until unreasonable hours.”
A Second Leak Adds New Context Ahead of the Reunion Airing
The newly surfaced audio comes shortly after the first reunion leak began circulating, prompting Bravo to investigate how the recording was obtained.
The network has since confirmed the audio was unauthorized and not tied to any cast member.
With multiple clips now emerging, the reunion is expected to provide long-awaited clarity on the timeline — and the shifting relationships at the center of the season.
