“Finding Mr. Christmas” saved the best surprise for the very end; and delivered it in full Hallmark vibes. With the Season 2 finale less than a day away, host Jonathan Bennett shared a video that instantly had fans smiling, replaying, and counting down to Monday night. Because when a Hallmark favorite shows up in costume and drops finale news? Yeah, people are paying attention.
In a joint Instagram video post, Bennett revealed that Kristoffer Polaha will be making a special guest appearance in the “Finding Mr. Christmas” Season 2 finale, airing Monday, December 15, 2025, at 8:00 p.m. ET on Hallmark Channel. The clip featured Bennett and Polaha behind-the-scenes, dressed in train-themed costumes while chatting about Polaha stepping in for the finale. It was playful, self-aware, and very much in the spirit of the show: festive, fun, and not taking itself too seriously.
A Hallmark Pro Pulls Into the Finale
The announcement came with a caption that spelled out exactly why Polaha’s presence matters. “@polahaha has entered the finale of @findingmrchristmas to give our guys advice from the pro of pros. Monday night on @hallmarkchannel see who gets crowned Mr Christmas,” Jonathan Bennett posted. No overpromising, no mystery angle; just genuine excitement and respect for what the finalists are about to face.
Polaha followed that up by commenting directly on the post, and honestly, it felt like the thesis statement for the entire series:
“Jonathan, so proud of the show you have created and the heart behind it. Community, compassion, and kindness are the cornerstones. Happy to jump in a[nd] share a bit of what I’ve learned along the way. Thanks for having me!!”
That response alone explains why this cameo hits differently. He’s not popping in for shock value. He’s there to offer perspective from someone who’s been exactly where these finalists hope to land. And having that guidance arrive at the very end (when nerves are high and everything feels real-real) feels incredibly intentional.
Also, let’s not ignore the visual here. The train-themed costumes? Peak Hallmark energy. We don’t know anyone who doesn’t love a train-themed Christmas movie moment. (Don’t pretend you don’t know someone with one that goes around their tree or a little village.)
The Fans Are All Aboard
The comments section quickly turned into a love fest for both the season and the finale reveal. One fan wrote, “This season was great as so many fellas were so talented,” which feels like a pretty solid summary of why viewers stayed invested week after week.
Others zeroed in on Polaha’s appearance specifically. “Super excited for the finale. Excited to see Kristoffer Polaha,” one commenter shared. Another added, “I can’t wait to see who the winner will be!! Love the hat 🎩 ❤️,” proof that the costumes absolutely did not go unnoticed.
And then there’s the pure finale-night excitement. “I’m so excited to watch the finale to see Kristoffer Polaha! It looks like it’s going to be fun! The costumes are awesome.” At this point, it seems like fans are just ready to grab a blanket, turn on Hallmark, and enjoy the ride.
How to Watch the Season 2 Finale
The Season 2 finale of “Finding Mr. Christmas” airs Monday, December 15, 2025, at 8:00 p.m. ET on Hallmark Channel. The final three contestants heading into the last episode are Craig, Rustin, and Angel (pictured above); each bringing their own charm, growth, and standout moments to the finale stage.
With Jonathan Bennett hosting, Kristoffer Polaha offering advice from the other side of the Hallmark journey, and one final crown on the line, it seems like the show is closing out the season exactly how it started: with heart, humor, and a whole lot of holiday spirit.
Who will become the next “Mr. Christmas” Hallmark star? Only time will tell.
