Bryan and Sarah Baeumler’s Caribbean resort is becoming a hot spot for HGTV stars! The couple, who chronicled their transformation of the Caerula Mar Club in the Bahamas on their show “Renovation Island,” have invited multiple pals from the network to the luxury resort this winter.
On February 27, 2026, Sarah shared a social media video from the previous weekend, when HGTV stars Alison Victoria, Taniya Nayak, and Scott McGillivray vacationed there with the Baeumlers.
In the caption, Sarah wrote, “Last weekend at @caerulamar with a few of our fellow HGTV peeps🤍 Great conversation, lots of laughs, a ton of sun & sand… these are the moments that remind us why we love this industry and the people in it. So grateful to spend time together in a place that means so much to us. Already missing this crew 🥰”
Bryan & Sarah Baeumler ‘Rolled Out the Red Carpet’ at Caerula Mar for Fellow HGTV Stars
The video shared by Sarah featured a slideshow of photos from the special weekend, including pics of the gorgeous group fishing off a boat, exploring the island, and snorkeling in a swimming pool.
The post also included a glimpse of a custom-made dinner menu from Lusca, the resort’s fine-dining restaurant, that included canapes and a chilled tomato consommé.
In the comment section, Nayak — who will appear on the new season of “Rock the Block” this spring — wrote, “One of the best trips I’ve taken in a long time! It was everything you just said and more- the ‘and more’ being that you and @bryanbaeumler rolled out the red carpet and showed us the greatest time! Love you guys and missing our little gang already!”
Victoria chimed in, “Missing you all! #crowdedclawtoe”
McGillivray’s “Vacation House Rules” co-star Debra Salmoni commented, “How fun is this?!? Love it all ❤️🙌🔥”
Fans had serious FOMO over the tropical group getaway, including one who teased, “You guys are living the dream down there. The rest of us chumps are freezing up in Canada”
HGTV Alum Jonathan Knight Visited Caerula Mar in January 2026
In January, the Bauemlers also hosted HGTV alum Jonathan Knight and his husband, Harley Rodriguez, at their island resort. Rodriguez shared a social media video of their trip, including flying in Bryan’s plane, soaking up sunshine on the sandy beach, jet-skiing, and enjoying high-end cuisine.
Rodriguez wrote in his caption, “Thank you @caerulamar @bryanbaeumler @sarahbaeumler for a slice of paradise 🏝️🩵” and Sarah replied, “So many laughs together ❤️ – loved having you both and can’t wait to do it again soon 🌴😎! Ps: call us if you need some help with the snow shovelling ☃️”
The Bauemlers purchased their beachfront resort in 2019, and HGTV cameras followed them as they renovated the rundown resort for “Renovation Island,” which premiered the following year.
According to a press release, they turned the “abandoned 10-acre property into a world-class island oasis complete with 18 luxurious hotel rooms, 22 ocean front villas, and a host of breezy resort amenities.”
